What it is: A waterproof, creamy eyeliner pencil that glides on effortlessly for a precision line or soft, smudged look.
Highlighted Ingredients: - Ceramide III: Locks in moisture and nourishes eyelids. - Margarita Powder: Conditions skin and supports collagen production.
Ingredient Callouts: This product is vegan and cruelty-free.
What Else You Need to Know: This highly pigmented, clean, and creamy eyeliner formula doesn’t pull or tug when creating a tight line and has plenty of playtime to blend it out. Bonus: The formula is enriched with ceramides to nourish eyelids.
Clean + Planet Aware at Sephora Products formulated without certain ingredients, including parabens, sulfates, phthalates, and mineral oils, from brands that have met our specific criteria for ingredient sourcing and formulation, packaging, environmental commitments, and consumer transparency. Learn more here.
I have mixed feelings about this liner. Pros: it glides on so smoothly and the color is beautiful. Con: it smudges onto the upper eyelid every time, so it's not great for extended wear. I've tried eyeshadow primer or concealer underneath and even powdering my lids after applying it to try to keep it from smudging, but it still does every time. It's a shame because it's a dream to apply.
Read more
dallasborn
Blue eyes, Light Medium skin tone, Dry skin
4mos ago
Wouldn’t recommend
The shade of brown was nice but that’s the only positive. Horrible to sharpen, breaks and is jagged. Smudged horribly in about 1-2 hours, ended up all over the outer corner of my eye. Save your money.
Read more
kyleneo
Hazel eyes, Light Medium skin tone, Normal skin
4mos ago
Recommended
The Best
The absolute best eyeliners. I have combo skin and in my experience its waterproof / smudge proof and it never irritates my eyes and it stays in place. The brown one is my go-to everyday liner. I just wish they sold them at more sephora locations. Please bring stock back asap!
Read more
Getfree22
Brown eyes, Light skin tone, Dry skin
5mos ago
All three colors smudged around eyes
I was so excited for this being clean, waterproof and pretty colors, I got all three colors! Unfortunately, I had to return all three as they smudged all around my eyes and don’t feel like waterproof at all.
Read more
FariaM
Brown eyes, Light Medium skin tone, Combination skin
Verified Purchase
5mos ago
Recommended
My favorite pencil liner
Love this stuff. It glides on no matter what type of eye shadow I have on. Best eyeliner pencil I’ve tried and I’ve tried many expensive brands.
Read more
greekgoddess7
Hazel eyes, Light Medium skin tone, Dry skin
6mos ago
Recommended
Worked well until it didn't
Loved how pigmented and creamy this was until I got about 3/4 of the way through and the eyeliner stick popped right out of the wood casing. It was pretty much unusable after that.
Read more
Lenacpl
Green eyes, Fair Light skin tone, Combination skin
Verified Purchase
8mos ago
I tightlined with this eyeliner in the morning and by lunch it had melted into the inner and outer corners of my eye. Doesn’t stay in place.
Read more
FEMMY
Green eyes, Fair skin tone, Normal skin
Verified Purchase
9mos ago
Recommended
Pleasantly surprised - just needs a sharpener
Shame that this doesn’t have a built in sharpener because it’s otherwise an ideal eyeliner. The formula is so smooth. I’m honestly surprised how low the price is for something that rivals the more expensive versions of this product.
Read more
gjil
11mos ago
Recommended
Love the way this color enhances my eyes. It truly is waterproof and stays put better than any other eyeliner after swimming.
Read more
Zostar
Verified Purchase
1yr ago
Pass
This product is not waterproof. It does glide on easy and is a great colour, but soon after it does smudge all under my eyes. I would pass on this one.
Read more
lilly007
Green eyes, Light skin tone, Combination skin
What it is: A waterproof, creamy eyeliner pencil that glides on effortlessly for a precision line or soft, smudged look.
Highlighted Ingredients: - Ceramide III: Locks in moisture and nourishes eyelids. - Margarita Powder: Conditions skin and supports collagen production.
Ingredient Callouts: This product is vegan and cruelty-free.
What Else You Need to Know: This highly pigmented, clean, and creamy eyeliner formula doesn’t pull or tug when creating a tight line and has plenty of playtime to blend it out. Bonus: The formula is enriched with ceramides to nourish eyelids.
Clean + Planet Aware at Sephora Products formulated without certain ingredients, including parabens, sulfates, phthalates, and mineral oils, from brands that have met our specific criteria for ingredient sourcing and formulation, packaging, environmental commitments, and consumer transparency. Learn more here.
-Ceramide III: Locks in moisture and nourishes the eyelid. -Margarita Powder: Conditions skin and supports collagen.
Dimethicone, Synthetic Wax, Mica, Polybutene, Beeswax (Cera Alba), Pearl Powder, Cetearyl Behenate, Isononyl Isononanoate, Polyglyceryl-4 Diisostearate/Polyhydroxystearate/Sebacate, Ethylhexyl Palmitate, Dimethicone/Vinyl Dimethicone Crosspolymer, Pentaerythrityl Tetra-di-t-butyl Hydroxyhydrocinnamate, Ceramide NP, Dimethyl Oxobenzo Dioxasilane, Isoceteth-10, Silica +/- May Contain/Peut Contenir: Titanium Dioxide (CI 77891), Iron Oxides (CI 77491, CI 77492, CI 77499), Ferric Ferrocyanide (CI 77510), Blue 1 Lake (CI 42090)..
The list of ingredients is subject to change, please consult the packaging of the product purchased.
Suggested Usage: -Apply the long-lasting creamy eyeliner directly to the upper and lower lash line and/or waterline for a sharp and precise thick or thin line. -Pro tip: The eyeliner has a little playtime, so smudge if you want.
Recycling Instructions: -Curbside recycle the cotton paper carton. -Clean out the remaining formula from the bottle. -Unscrew and discard the applicator and 50 percent post-consumer recycled cap. -Take the clean bottle and recycle at your local Sephora Pact Collective bin or mail to Pact Collective on Caliray at caliraybeauty.com.
Summary
5
4
3
2
1
4★
268 Reviews*
71%
Recommended
*Some reviewers received something in exchange for a review (free product, payment, sweeps entry).
