This has been my go to mascara for almost 2 years now. It will stay on, even at the gym. You will need a makeup remover to take it off. It melts off easily with the Garnier Erase It All makeup cleansing balm. I am a massage therapist and even on days with back to back clients this mascara stays. I also noticed my eyelashes grew in thicker and longer and I think it's from the oils used in this mascara.

I was super excited to try this newer to me brand out. The first application it definitely lifted my lashes but they were no joke impossible to take off the mascara. I tried multiple resources to remove them, and with my other preferred brand dried out, I kept using this tube. My eyes turn tomato red from attempting unsuccessfully to remove this mascara.

I have repurchased this mascara several times now. I have tried lots of other tubing mascara but this one has everything. I’m looking for all in one. It’s easy to remove. I absolutely love it.

Clean beauty that is comparable to Lancome, which I have sworn by for years. I'm less worried about what's in this mascara, it's buildable, it doesn't leave flakes or streaks on my brow bone by the eod (long lashes) and the removal is much better than wax-based masara. Really impressed.

I was a diehard Thrive liquid lash extensions girl until I tried this. I’ve tried all of the alleged dupes for their formula trying to find something a little cheaper, and that I can pick up at a physical store in a pinch. My biggest complaint with the drugstore dupes is that those formulas are so wet that it takes forever to dry, and I always wound up looking like a raccoon due to doing something wild and crazy like blinking or sneezing, and/or needing to do immediate touchups. I grabbed this on a whim because I was in a pinch and needed a new mascara ASAP. I am in LOOOOOOOVE with this formula. It’s the perfect balance of enough moisture to not feel like the tube has been left open for days, but dry enough to not feel like blinking immediately after applying is gonna leave you with dark circles under your eyes. It goes on so smooth (no clumps!), the brush does a great job at separating and lengthening. It doesn’t flake (even with my ridiculously oily eyelids), dries quickly, and lasts all day. Comes off beautifully with only water. It’s not waterproof, but it’s pretty water resistant, and my eyes tearing up or applying eyedrops doesn’t cause it to run. But the thing that really tips it over Thrive is the brown color. Thrive’s brown is more like a black/brown and I honestly don’t notice much of a difference between that and the black. Caliray’s brown is great for everyday wear. I’m a fair-skinned redhead and it’s perfect for a no or light makeup look for work.

Looooove this product, doesn't smear or shed easy. Ive even recommended this to my mom who has the oiliest eyes ever and it's the only mascara that stays on a while for her! Easy removal, no need for harsh products for that which is a plus. Dries fast so apply it fast and keep out of hot cars!

This product is truly a perfect choice for daily use. While it may not be particularly impressive or stand out in any extraordinary way, it is absolutely amazing for everyday activities. Its reliability and consistency make it an essential part of my routine, providing the functionality I need without any unnecessary frills or complications. Whether it’s for work, leisure, or any other daily task, this product consistently delivers satisfactory results, making it a dependable companion in my everyday life.

I have repurchased about 3+ times, this mascara has no fallout, leaves my lashes feeling lifted for an entire day of at least 8 hours of wear time. Absolutely ZERO smudging! Very easy to completely wash off and makes my evening routine super easy! Love x1000! Only mascara I will wear

This mascara sucks, and I definitely do NOT RECOMMEND it. The product claims to be volumizing, but it doesn't do that at all. My eyelashes look straight and weird, and they do not curl.

Obsessed! I love this mascara. I have oil eyelids and even the top rated waterproof mascara will smudge but this doesn’t. So glad i decided to try it.