What it is: A highly pigmented eye pencil with an ultra-creamy formula and an easy-to-use smudger tip—for effortless, iconic looks that last up to 28 hours.
Ingredient Callouts: Free of parabens, formaldehydes, formaldehyde-releasing agents, phthalates, mineral oil, retinyl palmitate, oxybenzone, coal tar, hydroquinone, sulfates SLS & SLES, triclocarban, triclosan, and contains less than one percent synthetic fragrance. It is also cruelty-free.
What Else You Need to Know: Available in an array of matte and metallic shades, this eye pencil has an enhanced formula that effortlessly glides on without any dragging. Featuring up to 28 hours of smudge-proof and waterproof wear, it allows you the time to apply and blend before it sets. The easy-to-use smudger tip makes creating your perfect look quick and easy.
Clinical Results: In a controlled study with 33 participants, results showed: - Smudge-proof wear for up to 28 hours on the eyelid and up to 10 hours on the waterline
The color is unique, but it fades a couple of hours later which is disappointing. I like the cream texture. With this price, I had hoped they made it a better quality
Read more
Lama28
Brown eyes, Fair Light skin tone, Dry skin
Verified Purchase
1mo ago
Worst eyeliner on the planet!
This has to be the worst eyeliner I've ever used in my life! Smears, smudges, transfers, you name it! Everything you don't want in an eyeliner it has. Not retractable either.
The shocking part is that it's $32 dollars! The $15 Sephora brand retractable eyeliners blow Charlotte out of the water.
Read more
Superdeva
Green eyes, Light skin tone, Dry skin
Verified Purchase
2mos ago
Recommended
My only go to eyeliner
I finally found an eyeliner that glides in my waterline. This doesn’t smudge like the others do. It is pricey but worth every penny. I wasted my money in eyeliners that I feel I have to keep rubbing on my waterline to have it show. So for anyone who needs an eye I we for your waterlines, this is it. My eye feels a little dry but not sure if it’s from this but honestly I don’t care. I love it.
Read more
nadyiah
Brown eyes, Light Medium skin tone, Combination skin
Verified Purchase
3mos ago
Recommended
BEST BROWN EYELINER
I’m obsessed!!! Creamy, stays, easy to smudge, great pigment… what more could you ask for?!
Read more
Tal01
Verified Purchase
4mos ago
It’s good when i tried on my hand. smudge proof, lasted the whole day. I tightlined with it multiple times just to see if i was the problem or not. Everytime i use it on my eyes it bleeds like crazy. Goes everywhere. If you don’t have oily eyes or if you’re not planning on tightlining, i would recommend. It’s honestly SUUUPER creamy and easy to use.
Read more
aelcott0
Brown eyes, Fair skin tone, Combination skin
Verified Purchase
5mos ago
The green color is really nice, but unfortunately it. It tends to smudge and leaves stains under the eyes after a while, which makes it look messy.
Read more
raghoodah
Verified Purchase
5mos ago
Recommended
Love the SAPPHIRE NIGHTS! 5 stars!
glad purchased.this combined w charlotte tilbury’s champagne cream shadow make blue eyes pop!very pigmented formula&easy application.comes w smudge brush on other side.this will be in continual rotation.
Read more
hotkymama
Blue eyes, Fair skin tone, Normal skin
Verified Purchase
5mos ago
Recommended
The color is beautiful.. It glides on beautifully and it stays. It did have a little bit of transfer but not too bad. .
Read more
Debc917
Brown eyes, Medium skin tone, Dry skin
6mos ago
Great color, awful formulation
I used this way longer than I should’ve because of how expensive it was. Always smeared and melted away after 3-4 hours. Kept having to reapply throughout the day. Will never purchase again.
Read more
andyq
Brown eyes, Light skin tone, Normal skin
6mos ago
Raccoon
Unfortunately smudges terribly - tried upper eyeliner, waterline in an hour was all black - no for me. Sephora brand much better
Read more
teenaisis
Hazel eyes, Light Medium skin tone, Combination skin
What it is: A highly pigmented eye pencil with an ultra-creamy formula and an easy-to-use smudger tip—for effortless, iconic looks that last up to 28 hours.
Ingredient Callouts: Free of parabens, formaldehydes, formaldehyde-releasing agents, phthalates, mineral oil, retinyl palmitate, oxybenzone, coal tar, hydroquinone, sulfates SLS & SLES, triclocarban, triclosan, and contains less than one percent synthetic fragrance. It is also cruelty-free.
What Else You Need to Know: Available in an array of matte and metallic shades, this eye pencil has an enhanced formula that effortlessly glides on without any dragging. Featuring up to 28 hours of smudge-proof and waterproof wear, it allows you the time to apply and blend before it sets. The easy-to-use smudger tip makes creating your perfect look quick and easy.
Clinical Results: In a controlled study with 33 participants, results showed: - Smudge-proof wear for up to 28 hours on the eyelid and up to 10 hours on the waterline
