What it is: An iconic eye palette that tells Mario’s dream color story with 12 signature shades in glossy shimmer, sueded matte, and natural metallic finishes.
Formulation: Pressed Powder
Ingredient Callouts: Free of parabens, formaldehydes, formaldehyde-releasing agents, phthalates, mineral oil, retinyl palmitate, oxybenzone, coal tar, hydroquinone, sulfates SLS & SLES, triclocarban, and triclosan. This product is also cruelty-free.
What Else You Need to Know: Mario’s original Ethereal Eyes™ Palette is his artistic vision come to life. Inspired by the timeless beauty of the natural world around us, the 12 shades and three finishes work in perfect harmony together. Be your own artist: Create infinite looks from everyday ethereal to special occasion. Glossy Shimmers are a first-of-its-kind-formula infused with pearls to impart a reflective, wet-like shine on lids. Sueded Mattes are enhanced grip and rich color. Natural Metallics have micronized pigments for a soft metallic shine.
This Set Contains:
- 12 x 0.04 oz/ 1 g Eyeshadows in EE 1 (matte creamy beige), EE 2 (shimmering champagne), EE 3 (muted matte peach), EE 4 (matte soft brown), EE 5 (matte cool mauve), EE 6 (shimmering silver pink), EE 7 (matte dusty rose), EE 8 (metallic medium brown), EE 9 (matte neutral brown), EE 10 (shimmering gold), EE 11 (metallic taupe), EE 12 (matte neutral rich brown)
I really wanted to love this product! Sadly I was disappointed, the pigment is very poor for such rich colors! And I’m a true makeup by Mario fan! The glitter doesn’t go on well, have to use a lot of primer. It will not go on over the other colors so you can’t build colors.
Read more
kdsawyer
Gray eyes, Light Medium skin tone, Dry skin
1w ago
Busted ! Crumbles easy !
Well it was shipped to me and the glitter on the bottom was all busted ;(
Tried to return it & Sephora in store wouldn’t allow it .. what a shame considering all myyyy points ! Ugh
Read more
PDAWG99
1w ago
Recommended
Shimmery
I think the packaging is cute and sleek.One of the pans was not glued in well. I think the shimmers are pretty but kinda look alike. The shades were warm for me so I really don’t use it much. I think they blend well and the shades are pretty. It’s just too warm for me
Read more
mechishaga
Brown eyes, Light Medium skin tone, Oily skin
1w ago
Colors are pretty, but there is a lot of fallout with the shadows because the eyeshadow itself is very soft. I was also very disappointed because two of the glitter shadows completely popped out of the pan by themselves. The palette has never been dropped, and this occurred within two months of purchasing the palette. When I reached out to Makeup By Mario, I was told that this is “normal wear and tear” or their product, which is crazy because I barely touch the glitter shadows and they clearly completely came out alone. So, it’s a pretty palette, but be aware that if you purchase it’s apparently normal wear and tear for the shadows to completely fall out and go everywhere
Read more
HLWK
Verified Purchase
1w ago
My experience with the quality :(
They are good palettes, but the design is flawed and the pigments aren't pressed well enough for the price; plus, they refused to send me a replacement even after I provided proof :(
Read more
AileenMore
Brown eyes, Fair skin tone, Combination skin
2w ago
Recommended
My favorite
This is my favorite palette out of the Mario Ethereal Eyes lineup and just my favorite palette in general. Which is really saying something if you knew how many I owned.
I was lucky enough to get this when it first released and was in the metal packaging, which I'm not sure if they are still using. The others in the range are the same aesthetically, but switched to plastic, which is probably less weighty for travel but also feels less quality in the hand.
These do have kick-up when you put your brush into them and the glitters have a bit of fallout. It should be noted they are a glitter, not a shimmer. They give a wet sparkle effect.
The color story and blendability to me made the palette a real standout and the mirror in the component is high quality. If I ever ran out, I'd buy it again.
**As a little additional note** the palette itself looks the same as it's pictured. I hate when I buy something, get it home and realize they turned up the saturation in the product shots and it looks nothing like what I got. The colors pictured are the colors you get.
Read more
ColliK
Blue eyes, Fair Light skin tone, Combination skin
3w ago
Recommended
Worth every penny, the difference between this eye palette and others is abysmal. Not only there’s virtually no follow out, but the quality speaks for itself. Love it! 
Read more
MK1860
Brown eyes, Light Medium skin tone, Combination skin
Verified Purchase
3w ago
Recommended
Immediate favorite
I have the new single eyeshadows from Mario so I decided to give this a try. It’s all I use now. The pigmentation of the color and the smooth feel is perfect!
Read more
Nic526
1mo ago
Recommended
Great colors, wonderful formula, so glad it was brought back.
Read more
GENXBUTEEJUNKEY
Verified Purchase
1mo ago
Returning sadly.
Sadly I have to return this palette. I am allergic to talc and I thought being a high-end palette most shades would be talc-free, but unfortunately 6 have talc making this palette unusable for me. I was also not impressed with the mate shades being so chalky and the special shades were just not as special as everyone hyped them to be. One the eyelid the matte shades looked muddy and chalky. I was hoping this palette would be awesome but it fell short.
Read more
udcrazynut
Hazel eyes, Light Medium skin tone, Combination skin
What it is: An iconic eye palette that tells Mario’s dream color story with 12 signature shades in glossy shimmer, sueded matte, and natural metallic finishes.
Formulation: Pressed Powder
Ingredient Callouts: Free of parabens, formaldehydes, formaldehyde-releasing agents, phthalates, mineral oil, retinyl palmitate, oxybenzone, coal tar, hydroquinone, sulfates SLS & SLES, triclocarban, and triclosan. This product is also cruelty-free.
What Else You Need to Know: Mario’s original Ethereal Eyes™ Palette is his artistic vision come to life. Inspired by the timeless beauty of the natural world around us, the 12 shades and three finishes work in perfect harmony together. Be your own artist: Create infinite looks from everyday ethereal to special occasion. Glossy Shimmers are a first-of-its-kind-formula infused with pearls to impart a reflective, wet-like shine on lids. Sueded Mattes are enhanced grip and rich color. Natural Metallics have micronized pigments for a soft metallic shine.
This Set Contains:
- 12 x 0.04 oz/ 1 g Eyeshadows in EE 1 (matte creamy beige), EE 2 (shimmering champagne), EE 3 (muted matte peach), EE 4 (matte soft brown), EE 5 (matte cool mauve), EE 6 (shimmering silver pink), EE 7 (matte dusty rose), EE 8 (metallic medium brown), EE 9 (matte neutral brown), EE 10 (shimmering gold), EE 11 (metallic taupe), EE 12 (matte neutral rich brown)
Suggested Usage: -Use any combination of shades to create an ethereal look, day or night. Each shadow offers sheer to buildable color. -Use your favorite Makeup By Mario eyeshadow brush (sold separately) for flawless application. -Pro tip: For the glossy shimmer formula, use your fingers to tap the wet-to-powder shadow onto lids. Head to Makeup By Mario’s Instagram to see Mario’s looks for inspiration.
Summary
5
4
3
2
1
4.6★
629 Reviews*
91%
Recommended
*Some reviewers received something in exchange for a review (free product, payment, sweeps entry).