I have been using this mascara since it launched. The formula is thick and clumpy because it makes the best looking eyelashes, especially if you use false lashes like I do! It makes my natural lashes blend well. I use a lash brush to comb my lashes and separate them after applying the product and it keeps them thick and long all day! I love that this is waterproof so no matter the weather or sweat or crying IT WILL STAY ON! Seriously BEST mascara ever. I loved it almost a decade ago and I still love it to this day. My only complaint is the packaging change lol I still have my original tube because I love the water droplets in the packaging design. That’s the only thing I wish hadn’t changed! Everything else? STELLAR! Highly, highly recommend if you want waterproof mascara and thick lashes. Again, just use a lash comb to keep them from clumping, because to me this formula is worth it.

I wanted to love this, because it makes my lashes look so voluminous. Unfortunately, even though it’s waterproof, it smudges under my eyes after a few hours. Soooo disappointing :(

I was excited to get this product in the mail, but when I opened it up, I saw that the waterproof version didn’t have any droplets on the packaging it also not dry quickly so if I rub my eye, it will smudge. I tried it on in store and it was great, but then once I ordered it cause it was out of stock and when I got it, it’s just not the same.

Love this mascara! It’s the only one that holds a curl and keeps the length all day! I was scared bc of the reviews but it’s honestly so good!

Bought a trial size and have used it on and off with a cheap drugstore brand, and this gives a nice lash look (not too clumpy) but will smudge under my eyes if I so much as look in the mirror wrong. Won’t be buying again.

Who needs a mascara that transfers and leaves dark residue under the eyes? Then this is for you. Otherwise, skip this.

Definitely NOT waterproof. Made the mistake of wearing to a lake trip with my boyfriend’s family…let’s just say thank god for sunglasses!

used to make my lashes look so good and just like falsies. i don’t know what happened but i think they changed the formula or something because now this mascara doesn’t hold a curl anymore. it used to add so much volume as well but it doesn’t add volume anymore unfortunately l.

Worst mascara ive ever bought here. Super clumpy. Like beyond clumpy. Wont come off. Gives it no length. And makes my eyelashes look Worst. Wont ever buy again

Love love love very thick and gives you better lashes then any mascara