i love!!! i tried the limited edition set they have right now with anywhere caffeine and wherever walnut in this lip pencil, and it comes with endless cacao, limitless brown, and dreamy pink in the original formula, they are smaller pencils, but it's an awesome set. buying that was my first time trying the extreme, and i love the OG ones but im loving the extreme! its very easy to glide on, and it stays for me! my only complaint is it can get clumpy or chunky? on your lips? i don't know if thats the right word, if you go over it more than once or twice, that also happens to me with the Maybelline lifter liners which i love but same issue. i'll definitely repurchase though! i'll always have the OG one too too though. i like using my initial application with the regular, and then going over once with this one. unnessecary work, but i really love the way this one looks. my favorite shade is anywhere caffeine number 1! wherever walnut, and endless cacao! i was surprised i enjoyed the dreamy pink as well!

I love this lip liner it really doesn’t smudge or anything and it’s the perfect cool tone

After the first time that I sharpened it, the crayon fell out of the wood pencil part. Since I don’t use it very often and it’s been a while. I am having a lot of trouble trying to get a fixed pencil from Sephora. 

I’ve been using this product for a few months now and I wouldn’t re-purchase it. Yes, the plus size is it stays on, but I find it patchy and not blend up at all.

this lip liner is so good. it lasts hours with gloss on without needing a touch up. i set it with powder and do two layers

I love this colour, I think it pulls more pink than brown however. Application is great, it’s very creamy but has staying power throughout the day.

I will be returning this was hoping this would be THE lipliner for me after seeing the description but this has no staying power. Its super creamy and easy to apply not drying but disappears even after drinking water for me.

I absolutely love the wherever walnut, regular makeup, forever lip, pencil. I’m so confused on why the shade in the extreme is so much different with the same name. I got this thinking awesome It will last longer but it’s a completely different shade.. I still love it but why don’t they just name it wherever walnut deep or something like Lee all together. Not a bad product just confusing when you expect the original color but it’s completely different.

I have Endless Cacao and Wherever Walnut in the Extreme formula. Both Shades are very pretty! But the price is dumb expensive for a lip liner that you (1) have to sharpen and lose half the product when sharpening, (2) is comparable to more affordable lip liners (Morphe) and (3) gets washed off at the end of the day. Also, idk if it’s just my lips but these don’t withstand lipgloss for that long :/ I don’t think this is so special that you HAVE to buy, it but if you have money to dish out, then sure

It’s a beautiful shade. But don’t knw the product left the outer coating and the entire product separated. Did not expected.